Where to Find the Coolest Hidden Bars in Manhattan

Manhattan nightlife is legendary, but what most tourists don’t realise is that beneath the shimmering skyscrapers and crowded clubs exists an underground world of hidden bars and secret speakeasies. These off-the-beaten-track Manhattan speakeasies offer a respite from the usual tourist track and a chance to see the less frenzied side of the city.

Whether you are a native New Yorker or a weekend tourist, finding out these secrets is like hitting pay dirt. The excitement of being provided with a password or stumbling upon an unmarked door never wears thin.

Why Hidden Bars Are Worth the Search

Manhattan speakeasies are not so much about being exclusive. These are venues where quality over quantity reigns, where expertly crafted cocktails make their way into comfortable surroundings. The bartenders are artists, the atmosphere is carefully curated, and the subtlety is all – and come on, there’s just something so cool about knowing that secret door while the world goes by.

The Top Secret Speakeasies to Check Out

PDT (Please Don’t Tell)

In the East Village, PDT is still one of Manhattan’s better-known “secret bars.” The entrance? Behind an old phone booth at Crif Dogs. Call ahead to book a table by dialing the rotary phone, then duck through the booth into cocktail nirvana.

Why they’re worth visiting: Their notorious bacon-infused bourbon cocktails and hot dogs.

Employees Only

This gem of the East Village is hidden behind an unmarked door with a small “EO” sign. The 1920s atmosphere is duplicated to the letter, from the white-jacketed bartenders who are the professionals they take themselves out to be to the “now old-fashioned” cocktail menu.

Why go: The kitchen is late-night and serves up some of the city’s best bar food.

Angel’s Share

Many tourists just so happen to stumble upon this little gem by accident while strolling past 45 Grove St. Typically, after picking up their car rental NYC vehicle. Concealed above a Japanese eatery in the East Village, Angel’s Share is sequestered in its rules: four customers tops, no stand-up comedy, and no cell phone usage at all.

Why you’ll love it: Japanese-style cocktails and a level of quietness that allows you to converse with your friends.

The Back Room

Lower East Side speakeasy bar with Prohibition-era vibe that functions pretty much like the same Prohibition-era bars once did. You’ll be sipping cocktails out of teacups and beer from paper bags just like you always have.

Why it’s worth it: The Prohibition-era atmosphere and retro charm.

Downtown’s Secret Spots

Death & Co.

Death & Co. in the East Village has a grown-up atmosphere, dim lighting, and a reservation policy, but it is not completely secretive. Its cocktail menu is one of the city’s finest.

Attaboy

Also from the same group behind Milk & Honey, Attaboy has no menu. Simply indicate to the bartender your wish and sit back as they create something heavenly for your palate.

The Garret East

Above a Five Guys burger bar, this speakeasy on the roof level offers craft cocktails in a less intimidating environment than some of the other secret bars in Manhattan.

Midtown’s Secret Cocktail Dens

The Campbell

Inside Grand Central Terminal, The Campbell resides in a refurbished 1920s office building. The era decor and high ceilings produce a movie-set ambiance.

King Cole Bar

More subtle than underground, the St. Regis’s King Cole Bar has a conspiratorial retro aesthetic. It gave birth to the Bloody Mary.

How to Locate These Hidden Spots

  • Do some research in advance. Every speakeasy has its own entry rituals, reserve policy, or other way of permitting people inside. Others utilize password rotation.
  • Search for subtle clues. A concealed plaque, an unmarked door, or a seemingly unrelated sign might be your entrance.
  • Talk to locals. Bartenders in regular bars may be aware of hidden bars in Manhattan and may tip you off if they get to know you.
  • Track social media heavily. A few speakeasies don’t have a presence online by design, but you might catch a glimpse.

What to Expect

Dress Codes – Casual dress codes prevail at most secret bars Manhattan residents go to. Cocktail casual or business attire is safe. Sneakers and shorts are to be avoided.

Pricing- Top shelf cocktails for top-shelf prices – $15-20 per cocktail on average. The experience and quality are worth the cost.

Atmosphere – Conversation and friendship take center stage here. No thumping beat or dance floor in sight.

Tips for Your Secret Bar Quest

  • Make reservations when possible. Popular spots fill up quickly, especially on weekends.
  • Take money. A few places are cash-only or accept cash.
  • Be respectful. The selectiveness of these bars is ensured by the behavior of patrons. Comply with house rules and respect other visitors.
  • Plan in advance. Some of the hidden bars in Manhattan are small and become crowded quickly.
  • If you’re bar hopping, this is an extremely useful tip. Use Manhattan car rental locations, like RealCar. When it comes to reliable transportation, make sure to pick a dependable company.

The Unwritten Rules

  • Never share location photographs on social media with exact addresses or admission information. Some of the thrill is discovering things.
  • Don’t arrive drunk. They respect quality over quantity and have the right to refuse service.
  • Tip generously. Bartenders are artists and should be compensated for what they do.

Planning Your Night Out

Take location into account when mapping out your route. Some of the best secret bars in Manhattan tend to be concentrated in certain neighborhoods, which makes it convenient to go to several in one night.

Begin in the East Village with PDT or Angel’s Share and then move through other neighbourhoods. The Lower East Side also has a few within walking distance of each other.

×